Anti-Immigrant Hate, Obama and Joe Wilson

If you are like me, and millions of others, you tuned in last night to hear President Obama’s health care speech to a joint session of Congress. And while the President gave us plenty to ponder, analyze and, I’ll admit it, still question about the current state of Health Care Reform, there is one moment that has overshadowed the night.

While pushing back on some of the myths perpetuated by much of the GOP and the rabid town-hall-goers, including the non-existence of the infamous “death panels”, President Obama was rudely interrupted by Representative Joe Wilson (R-SC), who shouted (at the top of his lungs) “You lie!“.

First and foremost, the fact that ANY member of Congress somehow thought it was acceptable for this type of outburst, directed at the President in front of a joint session of Congress, means he is lacking the type of judgment and temperament required of an elected official. That much is obvious.

But can we take a second to examine exactly what pushed Wilson to boiling point, allowing him to explode in such a violent and shameful manner? Of course, everyone’s favorite scapegoat – the undocumented immigrant. Check out the video below for Obama’s exact words and Wilson’s shouted rebuttal:

I have to say, I am highly disappointed in Obama, who ran on promises of just and humane immigration reform. He was only too willing to throw undocumented immigrants under the bus last night, not to mention his use of the term “illegal immigrants”. (If you want to debate why this term is a misnomer, please click here and read first).

Its incredible (though not surprising) that the topic of undocumented immigrants is what pushed a GOP member so far that they actually SHOUTED at the President.

From Mario Solis-Marich at NuestraVoice:

It joins the specter of an action by an African American President to the hatred of immigrants that you and others have used as political currency. I have to admit that this combination makes for political dynamite and of course since you have no real ideas for health reform divisive lies may be the only tools at your disposal. Therefore considering your weak and ethically compromised position I can understand the visceral impulse to scream out like a wounded animal. But Mr. Wilson that does not change the fact that the statement that the undocumented can benefit from health reform is a lie, you know it is a lie, therefore you are a liar.

Its like the misinformation and scare-tactics of the red-faced, screaming masses at Town Halls has infected even the most prized spaces for civil discourse. A joint session of Congress? This can’t be what our country has come to.

Not to mention, we are talking about human beings here – many of whom are caught up in a failing system. I wonder how Rep. Wilson would feel if he had to talk face-to-face with the people featured in CHIRLA’s most recent video on health care:

Thankfully, it looks as though Wilson’s lowest moment has become a rallying cry for those who want to pass real health care reform, and has even further delegitimized anti-immigrant politicians. Its a moment when the anti’s are showing their true colors – and they did it in front of the whole country.

As Liza Sabater at CultureKitchen said:

We need more Rep. Joe Wilson’s to speak out against human rights like health care and fair immigration policies. So we can show the world and voters why we need to get rid of them to save democracy.

2 responses to “Anti-Immigrant Hate, Obama and Joe Wilson

  1. Robert Gittelson

    The “Wilsongate” episode of last night was certainly a sad commentary on the fact that the “anti’s” are fueled far more from emotion and irrationality than from credibility and fact. Wilson admitted that, “This evening I let my emotions get the best of me.” I would argue that he let his emotions get the worst of him.

    In point of fact, the upcoming “Hold Their Feet To The Fire” rant fest promoted by FAIR, will further show the country just how far out in right field the anti’s are on this issue.

    I do want to note that it is Wilson’s fellow South Carolinian, Senator Lindsey Graham, who has been both the voice of reason, and the beacon of light from the right on the issue of immigration reform. I think that now that the country has seen what Lindsey Graham has been up against in his home state, we can begin to imagine just how much political courage he continues to demonstrate as the Republican leader on CIR in the current 111th Congress. True, his demonization of PRLDEF during the Sotomayor hearings was distasteful, but I suspect that Graham used those hearings to bolster his Republican credibility for his CIR campaign.

    I shudder to think about the intensity of venom and irrationality that we will see from the anti’s as this debate progresses. The CIR debate will test the strength of the fabric that unites our nation. The fabric will hold, but I suggest that we stock up on needles and thread just in case.

  2. Pingback: The Other Visceral Reaction when “illegal immigrants” are mentioned

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s