Groups fight “more of the same” on immigration

Last week, amidst growing frustration from immigrant rights groups and advocates, folks from FIRM groups in New York (NYIC) and Los Angeles (CHIRLA) took to the streets to protest the expansion of Bush-style immigration policies and legislation. While many of our groups (FIRM included) looked to the Obama presidency as a “New Day” for immigration, the reality of recent weeks has worn patience thin. The New York Times ran a story this week, highlighting the growing discontent and impatience.

First, there was the expansion of E-verify – a fatally flawed electronic verification system that threatens not only American workers but immigrants caught up in the endlessly bureaucratic immigration system. Then, there was the expansion of the 287g program – which gives local law enforcement the ability to enforce federal immigration law and is rife with racial profiling and abuse of power.

To be frank, we were promised a “new day” and we feel like we are seeing more of the same.

“We are expanding enforcement, but I think in the right way,” Janet Napolitano, the homeland security secretary, said in an interview.

There is no right way to expand flawed systems. They are just that; flawed. Of course enforcement has to be a part of a Comprehensive Immigration Package, but it should not be expanded outside of an entire overhaul of legislation. As Katy Vargas at ImmPolitic blog wrote:

There is a desperate need for broader oversight of our immigration policies. Escalating enforcement without reforming our immigration system comprehensively only exacerbates the problem and it will not render long-lasting solutions to our immigration chaos.

Last week, America’s Voice launched the “Enough” campaign, calling on the Department of Homeland Security to push for Comprehensive immigration reform, not an expansion of flawed and abusive programs. If you haven’t signed the petition yet, do it NOW. (Sign petition here)

President Obama promised a new day for immigration policy in America, but we have yet to see sufficient change coming from DHS. Rather than overhaul misguided Bush-era immigration enforcement strategies, DHS continues to pursue policies that have done little, if anything, to solve the crisis of illegal immigration.

These policies continue to increase fear in our communities and undermine public safety at a time when the nation is waiting to hear your plans for advancing real, comprehensive immigration reform.

While, on a personal level, I have been very disappointed with the recent moves from the administration (especially the expansion of 287g), I still have faith that the President is ready and willing to bring sensible solutions to the table to help fix our broken immigration system. I firmly believe that we need to keep up the pressure and make our voices heard in order to push for this. Obama (and the United States for that matter) can’t afford to not succeed on this issue.

One response to “Groups fight “more of the same” on immigration

  1. Robert Gittelson

    I applaud Rachel’s outspoken take on the issue of what I call, “Bush’s window dressing enforcement.” Furthermore, I echo her belief that Obama, Emanuel, et al are exceptionally smart and estute politicians that most assuredly have a plan to get CIR passed.

    I feel that the unfortunate few, (comparatively speaking), undocumented or “illegal” immigrants that have been caught up in this “selected enforcement,” are, in fact Martyrs to the cause of CIR. As much as I abhor the continuation and actual expansion of enforcement related issues that has been part of the first 200 days of the Obama administration, I recognize the political upside, (while also recognizing the absurdity of having to pander to the lowest common denominator of America’s social conscious).

    That being said, I admit to being particularly puzzled by this seemingly more enlightened administration’s unwillingness to tackle the issue of below standard immigration detention facilitites. I mean, where is the political upside to inhumane treatment?

    However, I am thrilled to have read in today’s NY Times, (in an article by Nina Bernstein), that tomorrow the Obama Administration plans to announce a series of reforms to our nations immigrant detention facilities. These reforms include improvements, added oversight, and in the words of John Morton, head of I.C.E., detention needs to be done more thoughtfully and humanely.

    My faith in Obama is restored. However, to paraphrase Rachel, we need to keep up the pressure and make our voices heard in order to push for CIR.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s