An Open Letter to Janet Napolitano

napolitanoLast week  Mallika Dutt, Executive Director posted an open letter to Janet Napolitano, asking that the Secretary of the DHS revisit unfair immigration policies that have led to human rights abuses and preventable immigrant deaths in detention. I think its worthwhile to re-print the entire letter here, it  originally appeared on the Huffington Post.

Dear Secretary Napolitano,

We are delighted to welcome such excellent new leadership to the Department of Homeland Security. On January 30th you sent a directive for an agency assessment of current immigration enforcement practices to be completed by February 20th. As part of that review process, I am writing to urge you to revisit unfair policies that have led to human rights abuses and preventable immigrant deaths in detention.

As an immediate step we encourage you to explore secure, community based alternatives to detention and make the incarceration of non-citizens a last resort. We also encourage you to limit the detention of vulnerable populations like children, asylum seekers, and the physically and mentally ill, unless such custody is necessary to national security. Ensuring due process and guaranteeing basic standards of decency and fairness for detainees should be the bedrock of all detention policies.

With more than 300,000 people in immigrant detention and the number of questionable deaths in custody rising every month, it is more urgent than ever to ensure safe and humane detention conditions. Here are a few stories of detained immigrants whose voices too often go unheard:

Warren Joseph
, originally from Trinidad, a legal permanent resident, served in the U.S. Army in Iraq. Instead of receiving help and support, he was detained and threatened with deportation because of actions caused by post-traumatic-stress-syndrome. During his three years in detention, Warren experienced and observed serious physical and psychological abuse.

June Everett, originally from Barbados, lost her sister, Sandra Kenley, while in immigrant detention due to medical negligence. Sandra was a 52-year old grandmother who had lived in the U.S. legally for 33 years and was detained for a minor crime that she had committed many years prior.

Juana Villegas, from Mexico, was nine months pregnant when she was stopped for “careless driving” (for which she was later found innocent). Instead of receiving a customary citation, she was detained in jail where she was shackled as she gave birth.

You can learn more about detention conditions first hand by visiting Breakthrough’s online 3D simulation at The simulation is based on stories, facts and figures assembled from groups addressing the issue around the country.

As President Obama so eloquently pointed out in his inauguration speech, “…we reject as false the choice between our safety and our ideals.” His leadership in making this a reality has been demonstrated by his call for the closure of Guantanamo Bay.

We hope that your assessment of current immigration enforcement practices will clearly show that we need to bring closure to similar conditions on American soil and that our national security will only be enhanced by restoring due process and fairness to immigrant detention.

Thank you for your time and attention to this critical issue. We would like to take this opportunity to wish you the very best in your new position.


Mallika Dutt
Executive Director

One response to “An Open Letter to Janet Napolitano

  1. you’ve got to be kidding me right?? pushing your far left, socialist agenda is going to do nobody any favours, particularly when people as it is are trying so hard to get justice against these ‘vulnerables’ as it is. Borders are there for a reason – to be obeyed, and not crossed. Not everybody is a victim, but the way ‘do gooders’ like you portray things you give everybody an excuse for criminality, illegal immigration and just general bad behaviour. You should be ashamed of yourself. It is possible to balance kindness and integrity with shrewdness and tough love. Your idea of an ideal world is one in which you think the most hardened of piss-takers is going to be cured with a candy and a hug. Get a life.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s